Your DUI Pro
Weekends & Evening Appointments Available 24 Hours

Free Consultation 701-746-4107

Toll Free 877-387-3524

The ethical problem with red light cameras

The movement to place cameras at intersections and traffic signals so that red light runners and reckless drivers are spotted has only increased in the past 20 years. Many states and major cities use such cameras, usually to catch people who blast through a red light. Other states that don't have the cameras seem to be considering them on a near-annual basis. It's a critical issue, both for public safety and for personal privacy.

However, there is also an ethical dilemma with these cameras: are they really being installed for the good of the public, or are they installed simply to make municipalities more money? And are these motivations mutually exclusive?

Consider that the state of Florida made $119 million last year from red light cameras, and the city of Chicago has made more than $300 million since 2003 from traffic cameras. Clearly, these cameras are a not-so-literal goldmine.

But the greater point here is that these cameras may inappropriately force fines on people, while failing to truly improve public safety. One study found that intersections that had cameras saw less fatal accidents -- but other types of accidents actually increased. Concerns have also been raised about the validity of the tickets themselves. The photographs taken and used to fine a car's owner presume that the owner was behind the wheel of the car. What if the owner let a friend or family member borrow the car?

These cameras may be well-intended, but there are some significant legal issues that they pose.

Source: Insurance Journal, "Red-Light Cameras: Safety Measure or Money Grab?," Tim Jones and Mark Niquette, Feb. 25, 2014

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Need Answers Now? Contact Us Immediately.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Contact Information

Dusek Law
712 Demers Avenue
East Grand Forks, MN 56721

Toll Free: 877-387-3524
Phone: 701-746-4107
Phone: 218-773-6934
Fax: 218-793-0013
East Grand Forks Law Office Map


Dusek Law Mobile App

Install the mobile application on your smart phone today!

  • National College for DUI Defense | MCMXCV | GENERAL MEMBER
  • Premier DUI - American Association Attorneys
  • NACDL - National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
  • state Bar Association of North Dakota
  • Minnesota state Bar Association

Method of Payment

VISA , Master Card , Discover Network